Russian crimes against Galician museums at the beginning of the World War ІІ: contemporary historical parallels and Polish-Ukrainian solidarity

Main Article Content

L. Khakhula

Abstract

Abstract. The purpose of the article is to provide a comprehensive analysis of the policy of the Soviet party authorities towards the museums of Lviv, Ternopil, and Stanislaviv in 1939–1941, and to project the Bolshevik destructive cultural policy onto the full-scale war launched by Russia against Ukraine in 2022. Particular attention is paid to the Polish-Ukrainian solidarity in saving cultural assets of Ukrainian museums from the Russian destruction. The scientific novelty of the study is predetermined by a special approach to the interpretation of the collected source material and scientific literature, which consists in forming a historical comparison of Soviet museum policy with the threats of modern Russian military aggression. Original narrative sources, such as, written in 1939–1941, the diary of the director of the Ethnographic Museum in Lviv Aleksander Prusiewicz, and a report on the state of Lviv museums, archives, and libraries in 1940, prepared by an unknown author, have been introduced into national historical science. The personal documents describe the atmosphere of the first days and months of the war, as well as the attempts of party functionaries to reorganize the East Galician museums and subordinate their expositions to Soviet ideological needs. Conclusions. With the outbreak of the World War II, the museum environment of Eastern Galicia underwent structural and organizational, personnel, thematic, and exhibition changes. In Lviv, the largest cultural center, 25 pre-war museums and 70 private collections were reorganized by the Bolsheviks into 5 state museums of historical, ethnographic, crafts, artistic and literary profiles. Private museums were liquidated, including the Lubomirski and Dzieduszycki museums, the museum of the Shevchenko Scientific Society, the Armenian and Jewish museums. Galician museums suffered considerable damage and losses not from hostilities, but from the unprofessional displacement and removal of artifacts. The cultural memory of these events consolidates Ukrainians, Poles, Lithuanians, and other European nations in the face of the Russian military and occupation threat to Ukrainian museums. launched after 2022 Polish and Lithuanian rescue initiatives were aimed at providing material and professional assistance in maintaining museum collections, financial and organizational support for Ukrainian colleagues, preserving and promoting cultural heritage through long-term museum exhibition projects.

Article Details

Section
Статті
Author Biography

L. Khakhula

PhD (History), Associate Professor at the Department of International Information Lviv Polytechnic National University; Senior Researcher Fellow of the Department «Center for Ukrainian-Polish Relations Research» Ivan Krypiakevych Institute of Ukrainian Studies of NAS of Ukraine, Lviv, Ukraine

References

References

Krutous, A. (1998). To the question of the formation of particular museum collections of Ukraine and Lviv in the XIXth – first third of the XXth century. Naukovi zapysky Lvivskoho istorychnoho muzeiu [Scientific Notes of the Lviv Historical Museum], 7, 3–13 [in Ukrainian].

Petrus, J. (1996). Lviv Museums 1823–1939. In: J. Ostrowski (ed.) Art of the Eastern Borderlands, vol. II. Materials of a scientific session. Kraków [in Polish].

Matwijów, M. (2003). The Ossoliński National Institute in 1939–1946. Wrocław [in Polish].

Dziuban, R. (2020). Cultural Assets of Lviv Institutions in the 1939–1953s: Displacement and Losses. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Tersky, S. (2013). Reforming the Museums of Galicia at the Beginning of the World War II. Viiskovo-naukovyi visnyk [Military Scientific Bulletin], 19, 146–148 [in Ukrainian].

Horban, I. (2010). Museum Life in Lviv. 1939. In: W. Walczak et K. Łopatecki (ed.) The state of research on multicultural heritage of the former Republic of Poland, vol. II. Białystok [in Polish].

Mankovska, R. (2017). Deformation Processes in Museum Activities: Western Ukrainian Regions in the 1939–1950s. Kraieznavstvo [Local Studies], 3–4, 239–255 [in Ukrainian].

Havryliuk, O. (2013). Museum in Ternopil: history of foundation and development. In: Ternopil centre of the Shevchenko Scientific Society. Collection of works, vol. 8. Museums of Ternopil region. Ternopil [in Ukrainian].

Gaidukevych, J. (2005). Museum activities in Ternopil region. In: Ternopil Encyclopaedic Dictionary, vol. 2. K–O. Ternopil [in Ukrainian].

Ciwkacz, O. (2006). From the history of the V. N. Smaglovsky city library in Stanislawów (1872–1939). Acta Universitatis Lodziensis, 13, 21–34 [in Polish].

Klapchuk, V (2009). Hutsul Land and Hutsuls: Economy and Folk Crafts (second half of the XIXth – first third of the XXth century). Lviv–Ivano-Frankivsk [in Ukrainian].

Quirini-Popławski, L. (2008). Hutsul Museum in Żabie. History of establishment, functioning, contemporary attempts to reactivate the idea. Płaj [Plaj], 36, 111–131 [in Polish].

Biedrzycka, A. (2022). Diary of the events of World War II 1939–1941 by Alexander Prusiewicz. Dzieje Najnowsze. Rocznik LIV [Recent History. Yearbook LIV], 4, 209–247. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/DN.2022.4.10 [in Polish].

Matwijów, M. (1998). Report «Archives, Libraries and Museums of Lviv», 1940. Rocznik Lwowski [Lviv Yearbook], 7–30. Retrieved from: https://lwow.home.pl/rocznik/archiwa.html [in Ukrainian].

Dashkevych, Y. et al (ed.) (2010). Vasyl Stefanyk National Scientific Library of Ukraine in Lviv: relocation and losses of collections: a collection of documents and materials, vol. 1. 1939–1945. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Naumenko, K. (2007). The City on the Eve and at the Beginning of the World War. In: Y. Isayevych et al (ed.) History of Lviv. In three volumes, vol. 3. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Kozlovsky, S. et Sytnyk, O. (ed.) (2010). Professor Leon Kozlovsky. Lviv–Warsaw. [in Ukrainian].

(1926). Report for 1923 from 1.VII. to the end of 1925. Chronicle of the Shevchenko Scientific Society in Lviv, vol. 67–68. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Materials on the activity of Aleksander Czołowski as director of the City Collections in Lviv, vol. 5. The case of reorganization of the Archive of Ancient Documents of the City of Lviv. Retrieved from: https://polona.pl/preview/372c9301-3925-43e5-95aa-d59a717e5029 [in Polish].

Biedrzycka, A. (2019). «Descriptions of monuments in churches and cemeteries in the Zwinogrod, Radomysl and Belocerkiv decanates» from the collection of Alexander Czołowski in the National Library. Krakowskie Pismo Kresowe [Cracovian Kresy’s Journal], XI, 142–144. DOI: https://doi.org/10.12797/KPK.11.2019.11.09 [in Polish].

Smirnov, Y. (2009). Activities of the Commission for the Protection of Cultural Monuments in Lviv in 1939–1940. Halytska brama [Galician Gate], 7/9, 30 [in Ukrainian].

Doroshenko, V. (1941). Libraries and archives in Western Ukraine under Bolshevik rule. Krakivs’ki Visti [Krakovian News], 250, November, 9. Retrieved from: https://zbruc.eu/node/58713 [in Ukrainian].

Halaychak, T. et al (comp.) (1995). Cultural life in Ukraine. Western lands: documents and materials, vol. 1: 1939–1953. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].

Vynar, L. (1976). Biographical and bibliographical materials of Yaroslav Pasternak. In: J. Pasternak. The Early Slavs in Historical, Archaeological and Linguistic Studies. New York–Toronto–Paris–Munich [in Ukrainian].

Hadaczek, K. (1904). Mikhalkiv’s golden treasures. Kraków [in Polish].

Bandrivskyi, M. et Krushelnytska, L. (2012). Mikhalkiv’s golden treasures and their fate. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Michałowski, J. (1991). Professor Mieczysław Gębarowicz. Scholar, guardian of national wealth, citizen of the city «Always Faithful». Rocznik Lwowski [Lviv Yearbook], 43–67 [in Polish].

Tersky, S. (2007). The Fate of Museums and Collections. In: Y. Isayevych et al (ed.) History of Lviv. In three volumes, vol. 3. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Sroka, Ł. (2018). In the Light of Vienna. Jews in Lviv – between Tradition and Modernisation (1867–1914). Berlin.

Chmelyk, R. (2017). Judaica in the Lviv Museum of Ethnography and Crafts: History, Collections and Current Status. In: V. Moskovich et A. Rodal (ed.) Jews and Slavs. The Ukrainian-Jewish Encounter: Cultural Dimensions, vol. 25. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].

Rudnytska, M. (ed.) (1958). Western Ukraine under the Bolsheviks: IX. 1939 – VI. 1941: a collection. New York [in Ukrainian].

Lytvyn, M. et Khakhula, L. (2022). Putin’s Russia: the beginning of the collapse of chauvinistic complexes and imperial ambitions. In: M. Lytvyn (ed.) Russia–Ukraine: betrayals, alliances, wars. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Soroka, A. et Atanesyan, G. (2022). Cultural cleansing. How Russia is destroying museums and taking art out of Ukraine. BBC News Ukraine. May, 19. Retrieved from: https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/features-61472927 [in Ukrainian].

Burdyga, I. (2024). Where to look for museum collections that disappeared during the Russian occupation. Deutsche Welle. March, 15. Retrieved from: https://www.dw.com/uk/kartini-zlocinu-de-sukati-znikli-pid-cas-rosijskoi-okupacii-muzejni-kolekcii/a-68515057 [in Ukrainian].

(2024). The Museum of the UPA General Roman Shukhevych. Retrieved from: https://www.lhm.lviv.ua/location/shuhevych.html [in Ukrainian].

(2024). 1907 cultural infrastructure objects were damaged or destroyed due to Russian aggression. Uriadovyi portal [Government portal]. January, 10. Retrieved from: https://www.kmu.gov.ua/news/1907-obiektiv-kulturnoi-infrastruktury-zaznaly-poshkodzhen-chy-ruinuvan-cherez-rosiisku-ahresiiu [in Ukrainian].

(2024). Destroyed cultural heritage of Ukraine. Ministerstvo vnutrishnikh sprav Ukrainy [Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine]. Retrieved from: https://mvs.gov.ua/news/zruinovana-kulturna-spadshhina-ukrayini [in Ukrainian].

Akinsha, K. (2022). Ukraine’s Museums in the Crosshairs of a Russian invasion. Wall Street Journal. February, 16. Retrieved from: https://www.wsj.com/articles/ukraines-museums-in-the-crosshairs-russia-invastion-kyiv-odessa-vasily-kandinsky-ilya-repin-golden-pectoral-scythian-gold-11645038773.

Kramar, R. (2022). Polish museum workers help museums in Ukraine. Culture.pl. June, 8. Retrieved from: https://culture.pl/ua/stattia/polski-muzeinyky-dopomaha%D1%96ut-muzeiam-v-ukraini [in Ukrainian].

(2023) Ossolineum in the Committee for Assistance to Museums of Ukraine. Retrieved from: http://old.ossolineum.org/index.php/komitet-pomocy-muzeom-ukrainy/ [in Polish].

(2024). About OBMIN. Retrieved from: https://obmin.eu/index.php.

Shveda, O. (2024). Preparations were made a month before the invasion. How the Lviv Art Gallery preserves exhibits during the war. Suspilne. Lviv. May, 18. Retrieved from: https://suspilne.media/lviv/748125-gotuvalis-se-za-misac-do-vtorgnenna-ak-lvivska-galerea-mistectv-zberigae-eksponati-pid-cas-vijni/ [in Ukrainian].

Mrozowski, P. (ed.) (2023). The Genius of Lviv. Lviv as a centre of art and its art collections. Catalogue of the exhibition. Warsaw [in Polish].

(2023) Research interview with Doctor of Historical Sciences Roman Chmelyk. October, 18. Author’s archive.

Platonova, A. (2024) Time to call a spade a spade. Interview with the director of the Khanenko National Museum Yulia Vahanova. Zhurnal pro suchasnu kulturu «Korydor» [A magazine about contemporary culture «Korydor»]. June, 19. Retrieved from: https://korydor.in.ua/ua/bez-rubriki/chas-nazvaty-rechi-svoimy-imenamy.html [in Ukrainian].