Desctruction of educational environment of the Kharkiv region by state authorities of the Russian Federation on the basis of testimonies of internally displaced people (2022–2024)

Main Article Content

S. Adamovych

Abstract

Abstract. The purpose of the study is to analyze the actions of russian authorities concerning the purposeful destruction of educational infrastructure in the Kharkiv region, which included repressive measures against Ukrainian teachers and scientists, russification, indoctrination of pupils and student youth, and purposeful destruction of educational institutions by shelling. Methodology. The author of this article in his research applies both general methods of scientific knowledge (analysis and synthesis, ascent from abstract concrete, system and organizational analysis, synergistic approach, modeling and forecasting) and special scientific methos (institutional method, comparative legal, statistical etc). Scientific novelty. Nowadays, the first doctrinal publications regarding destruction of the Ukrainian educational environment by the state authorities of the russian federation have only begun to appear in world science. They already have estimates that russia during the war deliberately destroys the educational field of Ukraine. However, they are not based on significant source material. Originality of research. Based on the analysis of data from open sources, the testimony of more than 1,000 eyewitnesses/witnesses of Russian crimes, which were collected by the Centre for Documentation and Research of War Crimes of Vasyl Stefanyk Pre-Carpathian National University, the author conducted an analysis of the actions of the Russian authorities to destroy the educational environment in the Kharkiv region, which was subjected to a destructive influence of Russian occupation. The results of the study will be useful for the implementation of the international information policy of the state authorities of Ukraine. In addition, the study of the means and methods of the Russian government, which it uses to destroy Ukrainian education, as well as the analysis of the consequences of the criminal actions of the Russians in the field of education, will provide a generalized picture for world science, which will contribute to counteracting the propaganda clichés of Russian pseudoscience, which justifies Russian aggression and continues to push Putin’s propaganda about Ukrainian Nazis, liberation from the repressions of the “Russian peace”, etc.Conclusions. The author of this article on the basis of testimonies of internally displaced people claims that destruction of the educational environment in the Kharkiv region is an element of russia’s genocidal occupation policy towards the Ukrainian nation. In his opinion, the shelling of the educational infrastructure in Kharkiv region by russian troops is purposeful, indoctrination and russification of Ukrainian children and youth is complex and is part of the russian genocide against Ukrainians, educators and scientists on the occupied territories of the Kharkiv region were subject to repression for their pro-Ukrainian position. The actions of military and political leadership of the russian federation in relation to the Ukrainian educational environment violate numerous international legal norms.

Article Details

Section
Статті
Author Biography

S. Adamovych

PhD hab. (History), Professor, Head of the Department of Theory and History of State and Law of Vasyl Stefanyk Precarpathian National University, Ivano-Frankivsk, Ukraine

References

References

Khoshnood, K., Raymond, N., Howarth, C. (2023). Russia’s Systematic Program for the Re-education and Adoption of Ukraine’s Children. Humanitarian Research Lab at Yale School of Public Health. Retrieved from: https://conflictobservatory.org.

Zamkowska, I. (2024). The System of Education as an Instrument of War in the Russia-Instigated. Ukrainian Crisis International. Journal of Education Reform, 1–21.

Adamovych S., Mykytyn, Yu. (2022). Prospects of bringing russians to criminal responsibility for war crimes in Ukraine in the context of the implementation of the constitutional right to judicial protection. Problems of implementation of the norms of the Constitution of Ukraine under martial law: materials of the international scientific and practical internet conference, 94-106. Ivano-Frankivsk [in Ukrainian].

Hnativ, О. (2023). Public International Law in the Mechanism for Preventing Violations of Peace in the Context of an Armed Aggression by the Russian Federation on Ukraine. Pakistan Journal of Criminology, 15/2, 293–303.

Basysta, І. (2023). Prospects for prosecution of violations of children’s rights in Ukraine and crimes against children committed by russian invaders during the large-scale war launched by Russia on February 24, 2022 (cooperation with the International Criminal Court). Constitutional rights and freedoms of a person and a citizen in the conditions of war and the post-war period: materials of the scientific seminar, 13–17. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Shchebetun, I. Mikhaylina, T. (2019). Protection of children’s rights in the occupied territories: international experience and Ukrainian realities. Politychne zhyttia [Political life], 2, 33–37 [in Ukrainian].

Karaman, O. (2019). Social characteristics of children and youth – victims of the hybrid war in the east of Ukraine. Visnyk Luhanskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni Tarasa Shevchenka. Seriia: Pedahohichni nauky [Bulletin of Luhansk Taras Shevchenko National University. Series: Pedagogical sciences], 1, 14–23 [in Ukrainian].

Khomenko, O. (2016). A long tunnel without light at the end: a high school on the territory of the “people’s republics” in the first year of the russian-Ukrainian war. Ukrainoznavstvo [Ukrainian studies], 2, 8–17 [in Ukrainian].

Gridina, I. (2016). The educational front of the war in the East of Ukraine. Visnyk Mariupolskoho derzhavnoho universytetu. Seriia: istoriia, politolohiia [Bulletin of Mariupol’s state university. Series: history, political science], vol. 16, 199–208 [in Ukrainian].

Vysoven, О., Figurnyi, Y, Molotkina, V, Brehunets, N. (2022). Repressive policy of the occupiers during the declared Russian-Ukrainian hybrid war against religious communities of Ukraine 2014-2022. Occasional papers on religion in Eastern Europe, XLII/6, 14–35.

Pashkova, O. (2023). Paramilitary camps for minors in the temporarily occupied territories of Donetsk and Luhansk regions: organizational and substantive aspects of work. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal [Ukrainian Historical Journal], 1, 20–35 [in Ukrainian].

Nenko, Y., Orendarchuk, O., Prysiazhniuk, Y., Shevchenko, O. (2023). Ukrainian education during War: a scoping. Revista praxix educacional [Рraxix educational magazine], 19/50, 1–18 [in Portuguese].

Esveld, B., Kvitka, K., Lokshyna T. (2024). Education in occupation: forced russification of the educational system in the occupied territories of Ukraine. Retrieved from: https://www.hrw.org/uk/report/2024/06/20/388318 [in Ukrainian].

U.N. Economic and Social Council, Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. (1999). Implementation of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Retrieved from: https://undocs.org/E/C.12/1999/10.

Losses of the Ukrainian education system due to the war: infrastructure and human capital. Part 2. (2022). Retrieved from: https://osvitanalityka.kubg.edu.ua/2022/07/15/ [in Ukrainian].

7 million children of war in Ukraine. Retrieved from: https://saveschools.in.ua/en/ [in Ukrainian].

Children of war. Retrieved from: childrenofwar.gov.ua [in Ukrainian].

Chernova, N. Izyum town of the Kharkiv region. The witness was interviewed on 18/03/2022. Archive of the Educational and Scientific Legal Institute of PNU (NNYUI of PNU) [in Ukrainian].

Ryabenka, A. Izyum town of the Kharkiv region. The witness was interviewed on 09/03/2024. Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Lytvynov, V. Chuguyiv town of the Chuguyiv district of the Kharkiv region. The witness was interviewed on 25/07/2023. Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Naretya, A. Balakliya town of the Balakliya Town Council, Izyum District, Kharkiv region. The witness was interviewed on 17/10/2023. Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Dibarov, V. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 22/03/2022. Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Huseynov, T. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 22/03/2022. Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Kalmykova, I. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 05/04/2022. Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Rudenko, I. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 17/01/2024 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Riyaka V. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 09/03/2024 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Basalyga, S. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 20/04/2022 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Skuba, O. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 30/05/2022 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Rubtsova, N. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 10/08/2023 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Kondratuvych, N. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 08/02/2024 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Hladkova, Yu. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 12/05/2022 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Mkhitaryan, K. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 24/03/2022 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Polishchuk, A. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 28/10/2022 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Tisheninov, V. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 13/12/2023 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Borys, I. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 12/04/2022 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Hypych, N. (2022). A specialized school №134 is burning down in Kharkiv. Retrieved from: https://kh.depo.ua/ukr/kh/u-kharkovi-dogorae-spetsializovana-shkola-134-foto-202202271429647 [in Ukrainian].

Makarchenko, A. Kharkiv city of the Kharkiv city. The witness was interviewed on 09/12/2022 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Ostashuk, O. Kapytolivka village of the Izyum district of the Kharkiv region. The witness was interviewed on 15/12/2023 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Zhurzhenko, T. (2022). Education Under Fire: The Ukrainian School System Under Occupation. Centre for East European and International Studies (ZOiS). Retrieved from: https://www.zois-berlin.de/en/publications/zois-spotlight/education-under-fire-the-ukrainian-school-system-under-occupation.

Klochko, N. (2022). Russification of education in the Kharkiv region: secret documents of occupiers are made public. Retrieved from: https://glavcom.ua/country/science/rusifikatsija-osviti-na-kharkivshchini-opriljudneno-sekretni-dokumenti-okupantiv-887747.html [in Ukrainian].

Ponomaryova, N. Buhayivka village of the Vovchansk Town Council of the Kharkiv region. The witness was interviewed on 29/08/2023 Archive of the NNYUI of PNU [in Ukrainian].

Voloshyn, M. (2022). Teachers were thrown “into the basement” and tortured: how the russians destroyed Ukrainian education in the Kharkiv region. Retrieved from: https://24tv.ua/education/okupatsiya-harkivshhini-uchiteliv-katuvali-zmushuvali-rusifikuvati_n2168784 [in Ukrainian].

Voloshyn, M. (2022). Hundreds of russian textbooks were found in the occupied territory of the Kharkiv region: what children were “zombified” with. Retrieved from: https://24tv.ua/education/osvita-okupatsiyi-deokupovaniy-chastini-harkivshhini-znayshli_n2172056 [in Ukrainian].

Situation in Ukraine: ICC judges issue arrest warrants against Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin and Maria Alekseyevna Lvova-Belova. (2023). International Criminal Court. Retrieved from: https://www.icc-cpi.int/news/situation-ukraine-icc-judges-issue-arrest-warrants-against-vladimir-vladimirovich-putin-and.

Plokhyi, S. (2023). Russian-Ukrainian war: the return of history. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].

The number of victims as a result of the attack on Khrakiv increased to 62. (2024). Retrieved from: https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-regions/3808234-kilkist-postrazdalih-vnaslidok-ataki-na-harkiv-zrosla-do-62.html [in Ukrainian].

Kravchenko, O. (2024). Russia is shelling Kharkiv again. Retrieved from: https://lb.ua/society/2024/01/02/591938_rosiya_znovu_obstrilyuie_harkiv.html [in Ukrainian].