Ukrainian historiography of the periodication of the new economic policy (1921-1929) in the years of Ukrainian independence
Main Article Content
Abstract
Abstract. The purpose of the article is to identify modern interpretations by Ukrainian researchers of the chronological framework of the duration of the NEP, to establish a specific date for its introduction and "disintegration", to determine signs of systematicity and functionality in justifying the appropriateness of using the phrase "new economic policy" to determine the limits of the historical period of social development.
The consistent scientific interest of domestic researchers in the topic of NEP issues during 1991-2021 is emphasized. The historical and theoretical problems of the new economic policy are analyzed mainly on the example of the Ukrainian village of the "NEP period". Attention is drawn to the substantiation of the chronological framework of the implementation of the new economic policy in the USSR and its features in various branches of the national economy.
The article states the peculiarities of the subject matter of the predominant studies of the periodization of the NEP, in particular the period of its formation and development, while the fact of leaving the NEP has not been sufficiently studied by historians. The stable scientific interest of researchers in the problems of the NEP during 1990-2000 is emphasized. At the same time, the number of scientific investigations by Ukrainian historians on the history of the NEP, its periodization in 2011-2021, has noticeably decreased.
It is emphasized that in the historical literature on the history of the NEP there is an identification of the periodization of the NEP with the periodization of its study, innovative approaches to highlighting the stages of the functioning of the new economic policy (1921-1929). Conditional interpretations of the NEP chronology are presented ("NEP era", "NEP period", "NEP years", "NEP times"), it is noted that without confirmation by specific dates, they are unconvincing and incorrect.
Article Details
References
References
Abrazumova, O. & Kornovenko S. (2017). Suspilno-politychna aktyvnist selianstva USRR u roky nepu [Socio-political activity of the peasantry of the USSR in the years of NEP]. Cherkasy: Cherkaskyi nats. un-t imeni B. Khmelnytskoho [in Ukrainian].
Bakumenko, O. (1992). Zdiisnennia novoi ekonomichnoi polityky v silskomu hospodarstvi Ukrainy v 1921–1928 rr. [Implementation of a new economic policy in the agriculture of Ukraine in 1921–1928]. Ekonomika Ukrainy [Economy of Ukraine], 3, 63-69 [in Ukrainian].
Bychenko, S. (2004). Spetsializovana silskohospodarska kooperatsiia – vazhlyvyi faktor pidvyshchennia efektyvnosti selianskykh hospodarstv u dobu nepu [Specialized agricultural cooperation is an important factor in increasing the efficiency of peasant farms in the days of the NEP]. Ukrainskyi selianyn [Ukrainian peasant]. 8, 235-237. [in Ukrainian].
Boiechko, V. (2004). Sotsialno-ekonomichna polityka radianskoi vlady v ukrainskomu seli periodu nepu v otsintsi vitchyznianoi istoriohrafii 20-kh rokiv XX st. [Socio-economic policy of the Soviet government in the Ukrainian village of the NEP period in the evaluation of the national historiography of the 20s of the XX century]. Ukrainskyi selianyn [Ukrainian peasant], 8, 59-64. [in Ukrainian].
But, O. (2008). Nederzhavnyi sektor promyslovosti Ukrainy v umovakh novoi ekonomichnoi polityky (1921–1928 rr.) [The non-state sector of industry of Ukraine in the conditions of the new economic policy (1921–1928)]. Donetsk: Yuho-Vostok [in Ukrainian].
Volosnyk, Yu. (2002). Nova burzhuaziia Ukrainy ta rozvytok pryvatno-pidpryiemnytskoi diialnosti na finansovomu rynku v roky nepu [The new bourgeoisie of Ukraine and the development of private entrepreneurial activity in the financial market during the NEP years]. Kharkiv: NMTs»SD» [in Ukrainian].
Voloshyn, I. (2019). Vyrobnycho-torhivelna diialnist ukrainskoi s/h kooperatsii v roky nepu: istoriohrafiia 1920-kh rr. [Production and trade activity of the Ukrainian agricultural cooperative during the NEP years: historiography of the 1920s]. Humanitarnyi visnyk. Istorychni nauky [Humanitarian Bulletin. Historical sciences], 31, 15, 29-36 [in Ukrainian].
Voloshkevych, H. (2002). Spozhyvcha kooperatsiia v URSR na ostannomu etapi NEPu (1927–1929 rr.) [Consumer cooperation in the Ukrainian SSR at the last stage of NEP (1927–1929)]. Ukrainskyi selianyn. [Ukrainian peasant], 6, 96-99. [in Ukrainian].
Hararuk, L. (2007). Birzhova torhivlia Ukrainy v period novoi ekonomichnoi polityky (1921–1929 rr.) [Exchange trade of Ukraine in the period of the new economic policy (1921–1929)]. Kyiv; Chernivtsi: Knyhy-XXI [in Ukrainian].
Heorhizov, H. (2003). Modyfikatsiia selianskoho mentalitetu za chasiv NEPu [Modification of the peasant mentality during the time of NEP]. Ukrainskyi selianyn [Ukrainian peasant], 7, 41-43. [in Ukrainian].
Holets, V. (2002). Robitnycha i promyslova kooperatsiia Pivnichnoho Livoberezhzhia v period nepu (1921–1928 rr.) [Labor and industrial cooperation of the Northern Left Bank during the NEP period (1921–1928)]. Siverianskyi litopys [Severyan annals], 1, 38-45 [in Ukrainian].
Hrechenko, V. (2015). Suchasna istoriohrafiia diialnosti militsii Ukrainy v roky nepu [Modern historiography of the activities of the militia of Ukraine during the NEP years]. Kharkivskyi istoriohrafichnyi zbirnyk [Kharkiv historiographic collection], 14, 142-149. [in Ukrainian].
Danylenko, V., Kasianov, H., & Kulchytskyi, S. (1991). Stalinizm na Ukraini: 20–30-ti roky [Stalinism in Ukraine: 20–30 years]. Kyiv: Lybid [in Ukrainian].
Drovoziuk, S. (2005). Dynamika suspilnoi svidomosti ukrainskoho selianstva v umovakh NEPu: istoriohrafiia problemy [Dynamics of the social consciousness of the Ukrainian peasantry in the conditions of NEP: historiography of the problem]. Problemy istorii Ukrainy: fakty, sudzhennia, poshuky [Problems of the history of Ukraine: facts, judgments, searches], 14, 442-465. [in Ukrainian].
Zhmaka, V. (2015). Torhivlia u mistakh Livoberezhzhia u roky NEPu [Trade in the cities of the Left Bank during the NEP years]. Sumska starovyna [Sumy antiquity], 36/37, 62-71 [in Ukrainian].
Zhurba, M. (2000). Radianski hromadski orhanizatsii natsionalnykh menshyn USRR v umovakh NEPu [Soviet public organizations of national minorities of the USSR in the conditions of NEP]. Pamiat stolit [Memory of centuries], 5, 137-144 [in Ukrainian].
Ivanenko, V. & Ishchenko, I. (2006). Ukraina nepivska: analiz sotsialnykh anomalii pivdennoho rehionu [Nepivska Ukraine: analysis of social anomalies of the southern region]. Dnipropetrovsk [in Ukrainian].
Kalinichenko, V. (1997). Selianske hospodarstvo Ukrainy v period nepu: istoryko-ekonomichne doslidzhennia [Peasant economy of Ukraine in the NEP period: historical and economic research]. Kharkiv: Osnova [in Ukrainian].
Kapustian, H. (2004). Ukrainske selo v umovakh radianskoho politychnoho rezhymu 1920-kh rokiv [Ukrainian village in the conditions of the Soviet political regime of the 1920s]. Abstrakt of doctor’s thesis. Dnipropetrovsk [in Ukrainian].
Katashynska, Ya. (2007). Funktsionuvannia pryvatnoi torhivli v Ukraini v roky NEPu (1921–1929 rr.) [Functioning of private trade in Ukraine during the years of the NEP (1921–1929)]. Pamiat stolit [Memory of centuries], 6, 97-103 [in Ukrainian].
Kozerod, O. (2003). Yevrei Ukrainy v period novoi ekonomichnoi polityky:1921–1929 rr. [The Jews of Ukraine in the period of the new economic policy: 1921–1929]. Kyiv: SPD Savchyna [in Ukrainian].
Kornovenko, S. & Lazurenko, V. (2004). Selo. Khlib. Hroshi: podatkova polityka radianskoi vlady v ukrainskomu seli u period nepu [Selo. Bread. Money: the tax policy of the Soviet authorities in the Ukrainian countryside during the NEP period]. Cherkasy: Vash Dim [in Ukrainian].
Kolesnyk, V., Kotsur, V. & Kotsur, H. (2002). Istoriohrafiia novoi ekonomichnoi polityky v Ukrainskii SRR [Historiography of the new economic policy in the Ukrainian SSR]. Kyiv: Khreshchatyk [in Ukrainian].
Kotliar, Yu. (2004). Selianstvo Pivdennoi Ukrainy: doba novoi ekonomichnoi polityky (1921–1929 rr.) [The peasantry of Southern Ukraine: the era of new economic policy (1921–1929)]. Odesa: TOV ViD [in Ukrainian].
Kotsur, V. (1999). Sotsialni zminy i politychni protsesy v Ukraini 1920–30-kh rr.: istoriohrafiia [Social changes and political processes in Ukraine in the 1920s–30s: historiography]. Doctor’s thesis. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Kotsur, H. (2001). Nova ekonomichna polityka v Ukraini: istoriohrafiia [New economic policy in Ukraine: historiography]. Candidate’s thesis. Pereiaslav-Khmelnytskyi. [in Ukrainian].
Kulchytskyi, S. (1996). Komunizm v Ukraini: pershe desiatyrichchia (1919–1928) [Communism in Ukraine: the first decade (1919–1928)]. Kyiv: Osnovy [in Ukrainian].
Kulchytskyi, S. (1999). Ukraina mizh dvoma viinamy (1921–1939 rr.) [Ukraine between two wars (1921–1939)]. Kyiv: Alternatyvy [in Ukrainian].
Kulchytskyi, S. (1995). USRR v dobu novoi ekonomichnoi polityky (1921–1928 rr.): sproba pobudovy kontseptualnykh zasad realnoi istorii [USSR in the era of new economic policy (1921–1928): an attempt to build the conceptual foundations of real history]. Kyiv: In-t istorii Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].
Lazurenko, V. (2003). Zamozhne selianstvo Ukrainy v umovakh nepu [Prosperous peasantry of Ukraine in the conditions of NEP]. Cherkasy: Vidlunnia-Plius [in Ukrainian].
Lazurenko, V. (2002). Podatkova polityka radianskoi derzhavy po vidnoshenniu do ekonomichno mitsnoho selianskoho hospodarstva Ukrainy v dobu nepu. [Tax policy of the Soviet state in relation to the economically strong peasant economy of Ukraine in the days of the NEP]. Ukrainskyi selianyn [Ukrainian peasant], 6, 109-112. Cherkasy [in Ukrainian].
Lantukh, I. (2004). Formuvannia infrastruktury rynku v Ukraini v roky novoi ekonomichnoi polityky (1921–1928 rr.) [Formation of market infrastructure in Ukraine during the years of the new economic policy (1921–1928)]. Kharkiv: Osnova [in Ukrainian].
Liaskovska, S. (2014). Uchast orhaniv derzhavnoi bezpeky u rehuliuvanni rynkovykh vidnosyn u period NEPu [Participation of state security bodies in the regulation of market relations during the NEP period]. Z arkhiviv VUChK, HPU, NKVD, KHB [From the archives of VUCHK, GPU, NKVD, KGB], 1, 7-28 [in Ukrainian].
Liakh, S. (1990). Naimana pratsia v silskomu hospodarstvi Ukrainy v umovakh nepu [Wage work in the agriculture of Ukraine in the conditions of the NEP]. Kyiv: Vyshcha shkola [in Ukrainian].
Marochko, V. (1995). Ukrainska selianska kooperatsiia. Istoryko-teoretychnyi aspekt (1861–1929 rr.) [Ukrainian Peasant Cooperation. Historical and theoretical aspect (1861–1929)]. Kyiv: M. R. Kots Publishing [in Ukrainian].
Maslov, A. (1995). Tovarni birzhi na Ukraini v period nepu [Commodity exchanges in Ukraine during the NEP period]. Ekonomika Ukrainy [Ukraine economy], 3, 62-66 [in Ukrainian].
Morozov, A. (1993). Selo i hroshi: ukrainska kredytna kooperatsiia v dobu nepu [The village and money: Ukrainian credit cooperation in the era of NEP]. Cherkasy [in Ukrainian].
Kulchytskyi, S. (Ed.). (2009). Narysy povsiakdennoho zhyttia radianskoi Ukrainy v dobu nepu (1921–1928 rr.) [Essays on everyday life in Soviet Ukraine during the period of the NEP (1921–1928)], 1-2. Kyiv: In-t istorii Ukrainy NAN Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].
Nizova, L. (2003). Promyslova kooperatsiia Radianskoi Ukrainy v dobu nepu [Industrial cooperation of Soviet Ukraine in the era of NEP]. Kyiv: In-t istorii Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].
Nikitenko, K. (2006). Metodolohichnyi instrumentarii doslidzhennia nederzhavnoho sektoru promyslovosti Ukrainy v umovakh NEPu [Methodological tools for the study of the non-state sector of industry of Ukraine in the conditions of NEP]. Skhid. [East], 3, 73-75 [in Ukrainian].
Onipko, T. (2009). Dosvid torhovelnoi diialnosti spozhyvchoi kooperatsii Ukrainy v umovakh nepu: osoblyvosti istoriohrafii 1920-kh rr. [The experience of the trade activity of the consumer cooperative of Ukraine in the conditions of the NEP: peculiarities of the historiography of the 1920s]. Hileia [Giley], 25, 78-87. [in Ukrainian].
Onipko, T. (2008). Zaklady hromadskoho kharchuvannia spozhyvchoi kooperatsii Ukrainy ta yikh rol v zdiisnenni prodovolchoi polityky v roky Nepu [Public catering establishments of the consumer cooperative of Ukraine and their role in the implementation of food policy in the years of NEP]. Naukovi zapysky [Scientific notes], 79, 243-255. [in Ukrainian].
Onipko, T. (2009). Podatkova polityka derzhavy shchodo spozhyvchoi kooperatsii Ukrainy v period novoi ekonomichnoi polityky [Tax policy of the state regarding consumer cooperation of Ukraine in the period of the new economic policy]. Naukovi pratsi istorychnoho fakultetu Zaporizkoho natsionalnoho universytetu [Scientific works of the Faculty of History of Zaporizhzhya National University], XXVII, 165-169 [in Ukrainian].
Paskalenko, V. (2004). Zamozhnyi selianyn v dobu nepu: komunistychna doktryna ta ekonomichni realii [Wealthy peasant in the era of NEP: communist doctrine and economic realities]. Ukrainskyi selianyn [Ukrainian peasant], 8, 257-259. [in Ukrainian].
Pyrih, O. (2001). Nep: bilshovytska polityka improvizatsii [Nep: Bolshevik policy of improvisation]. Kyiv: KNTEU [in Ukrainian].
Pyrih, O. (2002). Problemy funktsionuvannia vnutrishnoho rynku Ukrainy v period NEPu [Problems of functioning of the internal market of Ukraine during the NEP period]. Visnyk KNTEU [Bulletin of KNTEU], 1, 105-109 [in Ukrainian].
Pyrih, O. (2001). Stanovlennia podatkovoi systemy v Ukraini u chasy NEPu (20-ti roky XX st.) [Formation of the tax system in Ukraine during the NEP (20s of the XX century)]. Visnyk Derzhavnoi akademii kerivnykh kadriv kultury i mystetstv [Bulletin of the State Academy of Managerial Personnel of Culture and Arts], 1, 132-138 [in Ukrainian].
Svystovych, S. (2006). Hromadski obiednannia natsionalnykh menshyn Ukrainy v period NEPu: istoryko-pravovyi analiz pytannia [Public associations of national minorities of Ukraine during the NEP period: historical and legal analysis of the issue]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal [Ukrainian historical magazine], 3, 88-95 [in Ukrainian].
Sviatets, Yu. (2007). Ukrainske selianske hospodarstvo ta nova ekonomichna polityka. Kliometrychnyi analiz sotsialno-ekonomichnoho protsesu [Ukrainian Peasant Economy and New Economic Policy. Cliometric analysis of the socio-economic process]. Dnipropetrovsk [in Ukrainian].
Smyrnov, V. (2002). Suspilno-politychni ta ekonomichni peretvorennia v ukrainskomu seli v period novoi ekonomichnoi polityky [Socio-political and economic transformations in the Ukrainian village in the period of the new economic policy]. Kharkiv: Maidan [in Ukrainian].
Kulchytskyi, S. (Ed.). (2000). Sutnist i osoblyvosti novoi ekonomichnoi polityky v ukrainskomu seli (1921–1928 rr.) [The essence and features of the new economic policy in the Ukrainian countryside (1921–1928)]. Kyiv: In-t istorii Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].
Sushko, O. (2003). Nepmany: sotsialno-istorychnyi typ pryvatnykh pidpryiemstv v USRR (1921–1929) [Nepmany: socio-historical type of private enterprises in the USSR (1921–1929)]. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Sushko, O. (2003). Osoblyvosti stanovlennia ta funktsionuvannia pryvatnoho pidpryiemnytstva v Ukraini periodu NEPu (1921–1928): istoryko-teoretychnyi aspekt [Peculiarities of the formation and functioning of private entrepreneurship in Ukraine during the NEP period (1921–1928): historical and theoretical aspect]. Kyiv: Presa Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].
Farenii, I. (2015). Do pytannia pro ideolohichni nastroi v ukrainskii kooperatsii periodu NEPu [On the issue of ideological attitudes in Ukrainian cooperation during the NEP period]. In M. I. Stepanenko (Ed.), Istorychna pamiat [Historical memory], 33, 60-67. Poltava [in Ukrainian].
Shapoval, L. (2006). Suchasna ukrainska ta rosiiska istoriohrafiia novoi ekonomichnoi polityky [Modern Ukrainian and Russian historiography of the new economic policy]. Candidate’s thesis. Poltava [in Ukrainian].
Shapoval, L. (2005). Suchasna ukrainska ta rosiiska istoriohrafiia periodyzatsii novoi ekonomichnoi polityky [Modern Ukrainian and Russian historiography of the periodization of the new economic policy]. In Problemy istorii Ukrainy: fakty, sudzhennia, poshuky [Problems of the history of Ukraine: facts, judgments, searche], 14, 466-474. [in Ukrainian].
Sheverdin, M. (2008). Podatkove zakonodavstvo v USRR u period novoi ekonomichnoi polityky (1921–1929 rr.) [Tax legislation in the USSR in the period of the new economic policy (1921–1929)]. Kharkiv: Vyd-ts FOP Vapniarchuk N.M. [in Ukrainian].
Yampolets, P. (2012). Materialne stanovyshche miskoho naselennia Ukrainy v period NEPu: istoriohrafiia problemy [The material situation of the urban population of Ukraine during the NEP period: historiography of the problem]. Problemy istorii Ukrainy: fakty, sudzhennia, poshuky [Problems of the history of Ukraine: facts, judgments, searches], 26, 60-71. [in Ukrainian].