Russian Orthodox Church in Ukrainian social-political processes in the second half of the nineteenth century: historiography

I. Gorpynchenko

Abstract


Inroduction. Preparation of a comprehensive historiography of the social activities of the Russian Orthodox Church in Ukraine in the second half of the nineteenth century dictated by the absence of a relevant general works, the need of reconstruction of the Ukrainian vision of the domestic Church history of the post-reform era, the need of systematization of historical knowledge in this area to optimize future research.


Purpose. Creation of an original sketch of a holistic historiography of the social activities of the Russian Orthodox Church in Ukraine in the second half of the 19thcentury.


Methods. The purpose of historiographical analysis of public-political activity of the Orthodox Church in Ukraine in the second half of the 19thcentury realized the idea of methodological synthesis, in particular, the combination of a variety of methodological approaches, including postpositivistic, formational, civilizational, etc.


Results. The analysis of scientific works concerning the Russian Orthodox Church’s participation in public-political processes of Ukraine in the second half of the nineteenth century, identifies the main domestic and foreign, secular and religious historical Church schools, clarifies the features of their approaches to the coverage of religious and public aspects of the history of the Church in Ukraine.


Originality. It was found that the differences in the conceptual approaches of scholars who covered the whole range of the investigated problems were due to the different assessment not only of the national policy of the clergy but the nature of its social service.


 


Conclusion. The role of the Orthodox Church in political and social processes is presented from the standpoint of historians of different scientific schools: official Church, atheistic and objectively critical. In the historiography of the alleged conclusion about the structural heterogeneity of the then Church in Ukraine and the combination of the prevailing «security» with the marginal opposition trends in the attitudes and actions of the Orthodox clergy. The author offers prospective directions of further historical research, in particular: the history of the participation of the clergy in the implementation of the land reform of 1861, of the Zemstvo and judicial reforms of 1864; the Church’s influence on peasant protest before and after the liberal reforms, as well as the reaction of the Orthodox clergy to revolutionary processes; public-political activity of the famous Church leaders of the second half of the 19thcentury.


Keywords


Russian Orthodox Church, social-political processes, reform, counter-reform, historiography

References


1.        Polonsky, V. A. (1995). Orthodox Church in Russian history (the Synodal period). M.: Facilitating. – 107 S. (in Russ.)

2.        Pospelovskiy, D. V. (1996) Orthodox Church in the history of Russ, Russia and the USSR. Tutorial. M. (in Russ.)

3.        Litvak, B. G. (1989) Russian Orthodoxy in the nineteenth century. M. (in Russ.)

4.        Dmitriev, A. (1930) Church and the idea of autocracy in Russia. M.: Atheist (in Russ.)

5.        Mesha, G. V. (2007) Religious and social aspects of the development of the Orthodox Church in Ukraine years 1875-190. Donetsk: Nord-Press (in Ukr.)

6.        Tikhomirov, L. (1892) Clergy and society in the modern religious movement. Russkiy obzor (Russ. Review), 9, 224-240 (in Russ.)

7.        Labowsky, M. P. (1912) Importance of the Orthodox Church in the dispensation of public and social life. Kiev (in Russ.)

8.        Titov, F. S. (1911) The fiftieth anniversary of the liberation of the peasants from serfdom (1861 – February 19, 1911). Kiev (in Russ.)

9.        Rymskyi C. (1999) Russian Church in the era of the great reforms (the reform of the Church in Russia, 1860-1870-ies.). M. (in Russ.)

10.     Grekulov, F. (1931) How the Orthodox Church has served the autocracy. Kharkiv– Odessa: «Proletarian» (in Russ.)

11.     Barsov, T. V. (1896) Holy Synod in his past. SPb., 1896. (in Russ.)

12.     Solovyov, A. K. (2003) P. Pobedonostsev and policy of counter-reforms. Ural state University.Retrived from: krotov.Info/history/19/1880/solovyov.htm (in Russ.)

13.     Gorchakov, N. S. (1909) Law of the Church. Short course of lectures. SPb., 1909 (in Russ.)

14.     Kryzhanovsky, E. M (1890). Collected works. (Vol. 1–2.) (in Russ.)

15.     My Genesis. Diaries and autobiographical notes of Bishop Porphyry Rack. (1902). SPb. (in Russ.)

16.     Hrushevsky, M.(1925) History of religious thought in Ukraine. Kyiv: Osvita, 1992. (in Ukr.)

17.     Poyda, D. P. (1958) From the history of the struggle of the Ukrainian peasantry against the clergy before the revolution. Dnepropetrovsk (in Ukr.)

18.     Ignatusha, O. M. (2004) Institutional split of the Orthodox Church in Ukraine: Genesis and character (article XIXth – 30s of XXth). Zaporozhye, 2004. (in Ukr.)

19.     Runkevich, S. (1901) History of the Christian Church in the 19th. (Vol. 2, pp. 502–739). Petrograd (in Russ.)

20.     Reisner, M. A. (1883). Spiritual police in Russia. Moscow (in Russ.)

21.     Lyubimov, P. (1906) Principles of theological education. Spiritual school. Collection. M. (in Russ.)

22.     Lyubimov, S. (1906) Education at theological school. M. (in Russ.)

23.     Ovchinnikov, V. G. (1988) Orthodox Church in the history of our country. – M. (in Russ.)

24.     Persic, M. M. (1965) Atheism of the Russian working (1870-1905). M.: Nauka (in Russ.)

25.     Venediktov, P. (1930) Priests: the provocateurs, jailers, thugs. Moscow. (in Russ.)

26.     Church in the Russian history (1967) (IX century – 1917). (1967). M. (in Russ.)

27.     History of religion in Ukraine (1999). K. (in Ukr.)

28.     Pererwa, V. S. (2008). History of school education in the towns and villages of Kyiv region XIX – early XX century. Bila Cerkva: Publishing House. (in Ukr.)

 

29.     Mironov, N. (2000) Social history of Russian Empire period (XVIII-beginning of XX century). – SPb.: Publishing house «Dmitry Bulanin», 2000 (in Russ.)


Full Text: PDF (Русский)

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
Archive
2014 22   29 Том 328
2015 9   22 29
2016 1   02 3-4
2017 1 2 3 4
2018 1 2 3-4

User

Journal Content

Browse

Language