Ukrainian national historiography of the 1990th in perception of modern Ukrainian historians

K. Ivangorodsky

Abstract


Introduction. One of the most important instrument for keeping any process normal is the introspection by its subject that allows him to avoid mistakes and to refuse incorrect belief, ideas and stereotypes in perspektive. Such procedure is extremely useful for any national historiography, especially for Ukrainian, becouse its latest stage of development is not long enough as the independent discipline. Therefore, it is possible to recognize the professional Ukrainian historians interest to its first steps quitely natural taking in account their role in creation of the new researching field.

Purpose. As the purpose of this study is provided historiographic analysis of the modern historiography in context of the Ukrainian national historical science (the 1990ths) development. We are interested in the Ukrainian historiography exactly «national» by its orientation. In the structure of modern world historical science it looks like an unusual atavism which seems to many researchers outside Ukraine as the outdated archaism.

Results. The most problem segment of the Ukrainian national historiography in the 1990th, from the leading modern specialists historiographers point of view, is the theoretical and methodological (including terminological and conceptual) equipment of the latest historical researches. This circumstance was noted by such researches as V. Smoliy, A. Reient, A. Udod, A. Yas, Y. Kalakura, L. Zashkilniak, Y. Grytsak, G. Kasianov, I. Kolesnyk etc.

Conclusion. Was made the conclusion that perception by modern Ukrainian experts of the national historiography in the 1990th contains both sharp critical and positive remarks. It allows to hope for the further growth of historiography in Ukraine.

Keywords


Ukrainian national historiography, national history, historiographer, historian, methodology, historiographic canon

References


References

Reient, O. (1999) Modern historical science in Ukraine: ways of advancement. Ukrainian historical magazine, 3, 3-22. (in Ukr.)

Smoliy, V. & Udod, O. & Ias O. (2012) Institute History, Ukrainian History (Anniversary reflections are from the academic range of problems). Historiography researches in Ukraine, 22, 5-44. (in Ukr.)

Kalakura, Y. (2009) The Intellectual concord of the Ukrainian historians : dialogue of generations or conflict of methodologies. Eidos : Almanac of theory and history of historical science, 4, 262-269. (in Ukr.)

Kasianov, G. (2003) The Modern state of Ukrainian historiography : methodological and institutional aspects. Ab Imperio, 2, 491-519. (in Russ.)

Zashkilniak, L. (2009) «Floors» and «stairs» of modern Ukrainian historiography. Belarussian historical review, 16, 167-189. (in Belar.)

Kolesnyk, I. (2009) The Network model of science (new project of Ukrainian historiography?). Eidos : Almanac of theory and history of historical science, 4, 54-88. (in Ukr.)

Zashkilniak, L. (2004) Methodological aspects of world historiography process and modern Ukrainian historical science. Ukrainian historiography on the fracture of XX and XXI of centuries : achievements and problems. Lviv, 24-56. (in Ukr.)

Hrytsak, Y (2005) Ukrainian historiography. 1991-2001 : Decade changes. Modern Ukraine, 9. Кyiv ; Lviv, 43-68. (in Ukr.)

Taran, L. (1999) Leading tendencies of world historiography in ХХ of century and problem of crisis of modern Ukrainian historical science. Ukrainian historical magazine, 1, 85-91. (in Ukr.)

Popowa, T. (2000) Historiography science : problems of the selfname. Kharkiv historiography collection : the Category vehicle of historical science, 4. Kharkiv, 20-33. (in Russ.)

Zashkilniak, L. (2009) Notes about modern Ukrainian historiography. Ukraine of ХХ century : culture, ideology, politics, 15. Кyiv, 13-29 (in Ukr.)

Portnov, A. (2010) «Western» categories in Ukrainian post-soviet historiography : language changes in the epoch of translations . Modern Ukraine, 16. Кyiv ; Lviv, 153-182. (in Ukr.)

Isaiewych, Y. (2004) Ukrainian historical science: organizational structure and international contacts. Ukrainian historiography on the fracture of XX and XXI of centuries : achievements and problems. Lviv, 7-23. (in Ukr.)

Dashkewych, Y. (1996) Roads of Ukrainian Clio. About position of historical science in Ukraine. Ukraine in the past, 8. Кyiv ; Lviv, 54-63. (in Ukr.)

Hlomozda, K. (2006-2007) Modern look to the problem of re-thinking of the historical past. Confraternitas: Anniversary collection on honour of Yaroslav Isaiewych / Ukraine : cultural heritage, national consciousness, state system, 15. Lviv, 842-854. (in Ukr.)

Zashkilniak, L. (2002) International scientific conference in Lviv «Calls of modern historiography : world and Ukrainian contexts». Ukrainian historical magazine, 2, 148-153. (in Ukr.)

Kasianov, G. (2004) «Nationalization» histories : normative historiography, canon and their rivals (Ukraine of 1990th). Ukrainian historiography on the fracture of XX and XXI of centuries : achievements and problems. Lviv, 57-73. (in Ukr.)

Smoliy, V. & Gurzhiy, O. (1991) As well as when Ukrainian nation. Кyiv. (in Ukr.)

Kolesnyk, I. (2008) Ukrainian grand-narrative. Retrospective views and prospects. Eidos : are Almanac of theory and history of historical science, 3, 153-177. (in Ukr.)

Kasianov, G. & Tolochko, O. (2012) National histories and modern historiography : calls and dangers at writing of new history of Ukraine. Ukrainian historical magazine, 6, 4-24. (in Ukr.)

Hrytsak, Y. (2003) Ukrainian historiography : 1991-2001. Decade of changes. Ab Imperio, 2, 427-454. (in Russ.)

Zashkilniak, L. (2004) Preface. Ukrainian historiography on the fracture of XX and XXI of centuries : achievements and problems. Lviv, 3-6. (in Ukr.)

Sukhyi, O. (2012) Modern historical science in Ukraine: visions and directions. Ukraine-Europe-World, 10. Ternopil, 24-34. (in Ukr.)

Bolebrukh, A. (2008) History of history : pangs of of the repeated self-definition. Kharkiv historiography collection, 9. Kharkiv, 4-14. (in Russ.)

Matiakh, V. (2008) Modern Ukrainian novistyka and prospects of scientific searches. Ukrainian historical magazine, 6, 150-164. (in Ukr.)

Zashkilniak, L. (2005) Calls of modern historiography : world and Ukrainian contexts. Modern Ukraine, 9. Кyiv ; Lviv, 7-14. (in Ukr.)


Full Text: PDF (Українська)

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
Archive
2014 22   29 Том 328
2015 9   22 29
2016 1   02 3-4
2017 1 2 3 4
2018 1 2 3-4

User

Journal Content

Browse

Language